I know this is a triggering subject, but it certainly has been studied to death and found possible. Okay, here goes: I entered AA in about 1980, was on and off for a couple of years. Moved to another city and stayed sober for 20+ years. I sponsored lots of teens (I was one of the youngest women in that city, so was present during the huge influx in the early-mid '80s of teenagers), almost all of whom are sober, happy and successful now. Anyway, a while ago, I relapsed. I found myself drinking...normally. Didn't think about it when it wasn't there, never have gotten really drunk, never have blacked out, haven't had any life-damaging consequences from having relapsed. It didn't get worse, I'm obviously not dead. I was really confused.
As many of you know, that LAST person you want to go to about this is someone fully immersed in AA. My experience shows me that it's a bad enough trauma for relapsers who are dying and turn to AA members for compassion. Me? I am doing well...not kosher AA dogma for sure. So I researched. A lot. Found that it happens, being able to normally drink after years of abstinence. I would LOVE to hear from others who have returned to drinking without their entire world ending (other than their AA friendships). So, give!
imwanderwoman
Wed, 04/20/2011 - 15:17
Permalink
Relapsing and aftermath
I'd like to know just how many folks are out there who didn't die, get put in prison or institutions or have the wheels fall off upon relapsing after many years sober who actually are sure they were alcoholics when they begged for relief and got sober... I've been reading some studies (shocked me) and now seem to be one of 'those' people who can now just drink sanely without blackouts, getting tossed in jail or even getting drunk. Just wondering...and know I'm going to get slammed for asking the question. Still, I wonder how many others out there might write in. Like this site, most of the info's solid, so thought I'd post a new category/listing.
Jesus-is-Fraud
Sat, 06/18/2011 - 10:27
Permalink
An interesting thing happened....
I am getting on towards 22 years drug free.... This is an interesting time.
One of the mind sets that flavours the ferment is that of "Me, Mine and My Own" - this is my experience // and therefore this ONE (or number of) experience of this incident // treatment // attitude etc., defines the whole issue, and therefore everyone else MUST validate me and what I say by going along with it.
Not so.
As much as I despise the brainwashing cult of AA and many of the culti-mind setted members and the range of bullshit and game playing and all that crap - and the HUGE waste of time most of my years in AA treatment have been...
The facts are that for me with the the range of really serious abuse and neglect issues, the amount of head injuries, and having been destroyed by the consequential flow on experiences - as a result of growing up in my family - well when it came down to it - AA and NA and the meeting rooms were all that I had.
They were the ONLY places that I could turn too - and just fit in and go with the flow and pick up some life skills like talking, and finding my voice and learning how to count money and setting up meetings and basic book keeping and the legendary - "Doing Inventory".....
So here I am today.
I live in a small Australian country town, addiction to alcohol and the crazy family and small town clicques and gossip and being a fucking normal sleaze are endemic......
And just how mad you have to be in order to fit in with the crap - unreal.
So I keep my own company and that is good.
It's the sort of place that "masturbating yourself into a frenzy because so and so told you something about that person and Oh well we all know about that person don't we"...
There will be 500 piss heads at the local do, down the race track - all busy bad mouthing those who are into owning their own shit - but non of them have the balls to develop their own relationship - and to get their own opinions based upon their own experience.....
So stupid is as stupid does. That and their crazy partners and their crazy kids and their crazy friends and their crazy clubs and cliques.
I have no desire to use again - and I don't want to have to do that, in order to lower my standards, just to fit in with the crazies and their bullshit.
But of late.... one of the local junkie women who was having a hard time of it - because her mother is an absolute arsehole, and she fucked her kids up - like she had been fucked up, and the kids have grown up having trashed lives and trashed relationships and all the insanity and drugs and all... and then they do to their kids and the kids just keep right on living out the cycles of shame and abuse and all... and the only people any of then know how to relate too are people fucked up just like them.
That WAS the story of my life too - only I got out, stayed out, and the progression of recovery took over.
Well I laid a little sympathy on this junkie chick and she is as fucking mad as.... anyway after trying to invite me over to the pub for a drink the next time I ran into her - at about 10.30 in the morning - a few weeks later....
The shit just rolled on - and One day I ran into her again and rather than take advantage of the fact that she was in the presence of someone who was 21 years drug free and knew the ropes and how to deal with the issues - she chose to bury her head into playing a game on her mobile phone while sitting in the car.....
I just laughed and said, "what a wanker" and pedalled off...
So she starts bad mouthing me to her son, and this kid - all of 15 and 6' - starts bad mouthing me every time I pass him and he starts getting rather untoward.....
I ask his sister one day on a chance meeting in a shop - "Does he have a good relationship with his father? - the father is dead.
I asked "What about any uncles or cousins or teachers or anyone - does he have any older men to relate with and who are looking out for him?....
So I don't know what happened then, but this kid started coming around and throwing my bins at my door and kicking it and getting his idiot friends to join in - and because it's a small town, some of the other kids who would be getting into the booze and the drugs - with the 40yo drug fucked idiot in the end unit, started getting into this crap of throwing stuff at my door and breaking bottle around the place on my and the other residents foot path - and banging on the windows of my and other peoples units at 4am....
Well windows got broken and charges were laid and all that....
The shit bag boozer in the end unit - is facing eviction.... by the skin of his teeth.
The kids are basically NOT allowed back on the property to visit him in "unreasonable hours".
But you know..... one of the local junkies in the area, who refuses to deal with his shit and I think is hiding behind the label of "bi-polar", well you know he like to go on a bender now and then and hang out with the first junkie chick, and her delinquent son, and so this guy comes around and throws half a house brick through my window and he is a real fucking tool....
I heard the back door of the house next door close - a guy who he had been drinking with, the 1/2 brick was covered in moss - like all the bricks on the ground in the yard next door, the brick was an ancient local brick that was sandy and crumbly - like the bricks in the house and it's yard next door... and the guy was standing wayyyyy down in the back yard of a country house block, in the dark listening in to a conversation another person was having with the cops over the fence - at 11pm at night...
And a few nights later, this same guy drives his car up to my front door step and gets out and starts mouthing off how he is going to run me out of town and come back and shoot me - and - and - and and...
The laws of the land are that you can tell him to leave - but you can't beat the daylights out of him for not doing so... you have to call the police.
So went back inside to get my phone to record this "I am going to kill you" bullshit - and the phone took 20 seconds to boot up, then another 20 seconds to get a signal and another 10 seconds to read the memory and SIM cards.... and I was shaking and trying to configure the buttons and not clearly thinking and all - and by that time the guy had left.....
So I rang the police and he got nailed about half an hour later - and in Australia there is a 0% blood alcohol level for probationary drivers, and he at 45 years old... had been drinking... and he had probably lost his license before and was on one of the "get it again" come backs....
You could hear him screaming at the cop from 3 blocks away....
LOL
So anyway he got a fine for the threatening language, and he's done his license and his vehicles for a long time....
But the prick is a boozer arsehole - who hangs out with the other dead shits who love to slag other people off behind their backs and then takes it upon himself to big time himself in the process.
But what shook me was the "intensity of his crazyness" and it only happened for the first time in years that I actually contemplated returning to drinking as a means of escaping the insanity that I had been exposed too.
That some other fucking arsehole, had refused to take responsibility for, and had chosen to pedal it into my life.
So I did the fall back onto the tools that do work - such as "ringing a sponsor" or an "aware" or "on the ball recovering person".
I told them that in relation to my incest issues - that the stress of dealing with these sick fucks and their toxic abuse - was really causing me to fragment in relation to my incest issues......
I chose to handle the matter totally legally and to put it all in the hands of the police instead of rounding all these "fucking arseholes" and their bullshit and their crazy families up - and handling the matters in a way that would divert me from my chosen path in life.
And I chose to inventory it... pencil to paper - get it out of my head and down in print.
AA and NA aside - these ARE valuable skills.
So recovery for me is still an active process - that although I do not go to "meetings" anymore - because I am just tired of all the sick fucks in the fellowship - just as much as I am not prepared to entertain all the inbreds and the shit they pedal in small town life....
I do do a LOT of recovery type stuff on a daily basis - and yes I do like to crank on some AA speaker tapes etc., however I also do a far greater range of resources and materials than just AA or NA.
That is the difference for me.
I guess I could equate it as like the difference between being stuck upside down in a car, and then being able to right it, and finding it to have it's wheels stuck in a muddy ditch.
I mean AA and NA etc., do go some where, but it's more of a muddy rut, than a real opportunity to get out of the shit entirely.
Surpisingly some of the other 12th step fellowships like Sex Addicts Anonymous and Sex and Love Addicts Anonymous have been the most helpful in terms of gaining healthy relationship skills and learning how to have them, starting with myself.
My only real blunder into drinking was about 5 months ago when the biggest flood ever came through the place and there was alledged to be some nasties in the water and in the clean up, and I did not have any disinfectant handwash - so I found that PURE denatured alcohol was too strong and "fumey" - so I mixed it up about 60% water : 40% alcohol - in a "drinking water bottle"..... left next to the "drinking water bottle" that had the alcohol based lamp fuel in it....
So not remembering exactly what I had done, with what bottles, because some were partly drunk water filled bottles..... I picked up the bottle with the alcohol based lamp fuel in it - went to drink it and caught a sniff of near pure alcohol - and put that down; and immediately picked up the bottle beside it - with the 60:40 alcohol mix that was my disinfecting hand wash - and because my sense of smell had just been blasted with alcohol fumes from the other bottle - I did not smell the diluted alcohol in the second bottle......
And I took a HUGE swig - like about half of a 350ml bottle of 40% alcohol....
Before I went "Ooops".
Well I was kind of frightened that THAT amount of alcohol going into my system, might trigger off some kind of compulsion - but it didn't.
I did try to vomit it up and couldn't make it happen - fingers down the throat - strong salt water drinks, etc., etc., etc..
The paramedic could not give me anything like ipecac syrup - because too many people have heart attacks, and they could not pump my stomach etc..
I would not die from it - and so I just had to "ride the intoxication" out.....
I have a broken back, head injuries etc., and there are times when I do feel disorientated, and woozy and nauseas... that is standard fare from time to time.....
After 21 years of being drug free - that is pretty much what the alcohol "stone" felt like.
Dizzy, unwell and sick. And I thought "I get this for free without having to drink".
As I was walking around - still having to continue on with my business - I also felt, "I really do not like being stoned on alcohol - I don't like the feeling and I don't like being "out of it" on the alcohol.
I also connected with the fact that Methylated Spirits IS a fucking rough drop.
I felt unwell in the guts from that for a few weeks.....
I also came to the conclusion, "I don't ever want to use again - it's fucking shit; it's an impairment to being alive and fully participating INSIDE of my own life and participating within LIFE.
It's like watching a TV program on the Scottish Highlands, instead of going and hiking them.
It's that horrible disconnected, living death sensation.
So I am happy being drug free ONE day at a time. I am happy with myself for making that decision to do what ever it takes to get drug free and stay drug free - NO MATTER WHAT.
I am also happy that in amongst all the REALLY REALLY BAD BRAIN WASHING of AA and NA, I also got some REALLY FUCKING GOOD BRAIN WASHING....
These are what I call "Fundamental Principles" - by doing the things that keep one ordered, structured and grounded, instead of hysterical, clueless and spiraling out of control.
With the experience that I do have of being around AA and NA for a LONG time, as fucked as the fellowships are, and the "program of recovery is" as a way to get drug free and stay drug free - it's much like the Hitler Youth Movement;
As one guy said - "I was poor, my mother was a widow, we were often hungry and - and - and - the Hitler Youth Movement - they gave me regular meals, discipline, a place to belong, a nice uniform - good warm clothes and shoes, and we got to go on trips away hiking through the mountains and do all sorts of activities like gliding and shooting etc., etc., etc.
He said that without the Hitler Youth Movement - he would have had nothing.
It's the same for me with NA and AA etc.. these things were important and they still are important - BUT like how the Hitler Youth Movement was a great way to indoctrinate the entire youth of a country as a form of preemptive training for war in the armed forces..... NA and AA - those people - even with all their mind fuck bullshit - some of them were kind, and there were significant times in my life if I had not of had the routine of going to meetings and going to more meetings and going to more meetings and ringing my sponsor and going to more meetings and doing my inventory etc., I would have slid right off the edge - because there was things going on in my life from time to time that were just too fucking hard to cope with - and I could not have gotten through them without these people and without the structure and meetings of NA and AA.
I mean the XMAS dinner meetings were kind of ordinary - but I had a place were I belonged, where I could go to and where I did not have to be alone.....
And that was good up till the day that I could accept that christmas was just a bogus imposition and I didn't have to feel down about any of it or myself because of how the other members of my family played their cards in regards to maintaining contact or holding celebratory get togethers...
For me - every day is a day of celebration, it's brilliant being drug free, and good, bad or indifferent, I am grateful for all that I have and for all that I have experienced - because today I have so much more to give. I am a richer and more capable person both as a result of these experiences and what I have chosen to do about them.
istj04
Wed, 06/29/2011 - 13:20
Permalink
20/20 DVD spells this out. . . .
Excellent DVD of an old "20/20" episode from 2000 that discusses the idea of going back to "moderation" (alcohol only!) after having an addiction to it. Marc Kern is featured in this episode. Its called "Drinking: Are You In Control"?, and can be purchased at Amazon.com. Marc Kern is also the source behind "habitdoc.com".
massive
Tue, 12/06/2011 - 21:19
Permalink
drinking after many years sober
Honestly I am happy for you. I stopped at 18 and sober 36 years and left AA last spring for Good. I F****king hate its Bullshit. Anyway....I know a few who posted on the ST thread whY I left AA who were young and successfully drinking moderately. Forget talking to AA koolaid drinking fools about it. There are alot our there, sorry to say not me. But I interviewed one guy for my film who is doing it successfully. I hate the black & white think in AA mindset. Enjoy! my blogs are www.leavingaa.com and www.stop13stepinaa.wordpress.com actually many early posts on the 13 stepping blog told of stories where the woman left AA and did fine away from it.
I had alot of sad days as I was leaving because I felt my life was ripped off from me in a way from all of AA' depressing belief systems. I actually morned my years in AA LOL....
WE are like men who have lost their legs they never grow new ones. How Screwed up is that?
Massive
KURVON
Thu, 04/21/2011 - 01:04
Permalink
Relapsing
I don't think it's wrong and I ain't slamming anybody, but I wonder what, if any good can come from experimenting with something that at some point in your life caused you harm and, after a long period of time with no harm you decide to see if you want to harm yourself again. Have a Coke. What's the point with dicing with something which you know causes you harm. Just Saying.
Peace
djc
Orange
Fri, 05/06/2011 - 16:19
Permalink
experimenting
Yes, I agree there. I only "experimented" once, after three years of perfect sobriety. Alas, I slipped right back down that slippery slope and went out for 9 years, until things got really bad. Some experiments are better left undone.
Have a good day now.
== Orange
istj04
Sat, 06/04/2011 - 21:05
Permalink
"20/20" Episode
I show my DUI clients an old 2000 episode of 20/20 (called "Drinking: Are YOU In Control?"), in which the idea of "abstinence vs. moderation" is discussed, along with the "disease vs. choice", and "genetics vs. behavior" debate on alcohol addiction. A portion of an actual AA meeting is also on this episode (just a few minutes worth). Its a good episode to advance a discussion on this very issue. A copy of it can be obtained from amazon.com
istj04
Wed, 06/29/2011 - 13:26
Permalink
Don't 12-Steppers FEED that mentality?
The problem with the "You will be back to where you left off" mentality (when it comes to "relapsing") is that its ALL FED BY 12-STEPPERS! This is one of their bullshit scare tactics! The fact is, NO ONE can force a person to use a drug MORE then THEY INTENDED TO USE IT! After all, is there such a thing as "forced" drug use, or a "forced" relapse? I think you need to watch that DVD I mentioned, Orange! ;)
Orange
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 15:23
Permalink
RE: "You will be back to where you left off"
Actually, what I got from my child-molesting 12-Step counselor was that "my disease" must have progressed during the time that I wasn't drinking. He didn't want to hear that I quickly returned to the same level of drinking as I was at three years earlier. He wanted to hear the scare story that my "alcoholism had progressed" even when I wasn't drinking, and things were much worse.
Well, they weren't. It took more years of drinking for my comfort zone of drinking to escalate.
Pennywise
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 15:47
Permalink
They also tell you that you
They also tell you that you stop developing mentally at the age you start boozing. So if you started drinking at 15, they say you have the mind of a 15-year-old even if you are 45. This is often presented as a proven medical fact. I see no evidence of it, yet it is still touted as an indisputable truth. Has anyone else been told this?
"Hokey religions and ancient weapons are no match for a good blaster at your side, kid."
msafrany
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 16:37
Permalink
They told me so
I heard that one all the time. If I started back up again, I will be right where I left off at 23, emotionally and mentally, even though I am 45 yrs old now.
And when I sobered up at 23, I was like a 16 year old, the age I was when I started getting high. And regardless of how many years sober you have, one drink and you return back to non-spiritual status. Do not pass go. And there is this crap about "emotional sobriety" that Bill W once wrote that was quoted all the time in my neck of the woods.
marietta davis
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 16:09
Permalink
a l'orange
Do you believe your experience must be true for everyone?
By the way, "The Configure Block" - if access is denied, is it plausible that censorship or exclusion is beginning to surface on the Orange Pages Forum? Please do explain. Thank you.
Pennywise
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 16:18
Permalink
Do you believe your
Do you believe your experience must be true for everyone?
The folks in the 12 Step industry seems to think that their ideas about addictions are true for everyone. So if anyone is guilty of making sweeping generalizations, it's them.
"Hokey religions and ancient weapons are no match for a good blaster at your side, kid."
marietta davis
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 18:05
Permalink
let orange speak
The question was not an accusation. I asked it of Orange. He will answer for himself if he wishes. Meanwhile, why the end-run? Why so trigger-happy with your (unsolicited) retort?
Pennywise
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 18:09
Permalink
I will respond to whatever I
I will respond to whatever I wish to respond to, solicited or not.
"Hokey religions and ancient weapons are no match for a good blaster at your side, kid."
marietta davis
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 18:19
Permalink
you're in this deep
Then maybe you would be good enough to explain the nasty, accusatory undertone of your response to the question I asked Orange.
Pennywise
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 18:37
Permalink
You're reading too much into
You're reading too much into it. Nothing nasty at all. The 12 Step counselors make up a whole bunch of nonsense and then pass it off as proven truth that applies to everyone. They make a lot of money off peddling that pseudo-science, and I felt like commenting. The undertones that you chose to read into my post are of your own making. If I were to accuse you of something, rest assured I'd do you the courtesy of doing it directly.
"Hokey religions and ancient weapons are no match for a good blaster at your side, kid."
marietta davis
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 19:09
Permalink
ok ...
A curious sort of integrity ... nonetheless, one with which I can deal. Thanks.
live_free_or_die
Thu, 01/05/2012 - 03:04
Permalink
The head meds again
The meds are at it again. Misinterpreting a post on the forum. Paranoia. Delusional. Irrational behavior.
A direct result of 23 years of drugging.
Marietta, you have hidden behind the wall of denial long enough. Time for a new approach. A new Sponsor.
Try Clancy A. Imislund.
Sponsors: Have one.....use one.....be one.
Alcoholics Anonymous: MyNotGodHasItCovered®
http://www.expaa.org/
http://bereanresearch.com/
http://badrecovery.blogspot.com/
NOT AA:
Rational Recovery, SOS, HAMS
http://alcoholabusesolutions.com/
alkieanon
Sat, 03/10/2012 - 13:58
Permalink
Sweeping Generalizations
Who's guilty of making sweeping generalizations?
http://www.orange-papers.org/forum/comment/19159#comment-19159
Pagans, Witches, Thieves, Murderers and Rapists
http://www.orange-papers.org/forum/comment/10936#comment-10936
con men, rapists and murderers
http://www.orange-papers.org/forum/node/675
thieves, rapists, scam artists and murderers
http://www.orange-papers.org/forum/comment/10759#comment-10759
thieves and murderers
http://www.orange-papers.org/forum/comment/8400#comment-8400
rapists sexual predators murderers scammers pedophiles wife beaters manipulators hypocrites losers
Clara
Mon, 02/27/2012 - 19:39
Permalink
Thank you, Orange. Not worth
Thank you, Orange. Not worth it to me even if I thought I wanted it. Just because people think they are drinking normally... That is often how it starts out. "Oh, I CAN stop at two." Ask them again in a year.
Remember Christopher Stevens when you vote.
catwalksintoabar
Fri, 04/22/2011 - 14:50
Permalink
LOL, I was one of those teens! It's called "Maturing Out."
I'mWanderWoman, please just wait for others. It's called "Maturing Out" and was first described in the 1960s/1970s by a Social Worker studying the (then) heroine problem in NYC.
(I'm not sure why Kurvon decided to slam you for "experimenting" on this topic. Are certain topics not allowed? If so, yeah, go drink a coke, Kurvon. And thanks for your input....In the meantime, I'll be naughty and talk about drinking.)
I had been one of those (troubled) teens who found her way into aa in the 80s. I stayed into the 00s. I had 20+ years of abstinence when I left. (I left aa for other reasons, probably most related to the topic of "there's no exit ever, not matter what.")
The one significant difference between your tale and mine is that I didn't relapse. I chose to drink again. And I chose it knowing full well that alcohol was no longer a problem for me.
How did I know it wasn't a problem? Well, sometime between year 15-18, I had inadvertently consumed alcohol, and I hadn't even noticed! After it was pointed out to me by aa members (Can you say "WHOOPSIE!" I was a frigging old-timer getting this 'lapse' pointed out!!!!!), it occurred to me that if aa doctrine was right, I should have noticed. And if aa doctrine was right, wasn't alcohol supposed to send me mad for drinking? But it didn't send me mad, and I hadn't even noticed.
Sometime later, after I had processed the feelings of unending servitude and fear, I left aa. (Insert the relief to NOT be taking my own inventory every 5 minutes here.) About 2 years later, I experimented with alcohol.
Do I get drunk? No, because it's yucky.
Have I gotten drunk? Yes. I still remember the one large bottle of wine which got me sick. I haven't repeated that.
Do I like drinking? Well, yes. A little is nice, but too much is kind of horrible.
I mentioned earlier the phrase "Maturing Out." I had known more about this topic a few years ago when it was important to me. (I know I read Stanton Peele's letters and I know I did more follow-up research.) My recollection was that, after its heyday, a social worker went to find all of those troublesome late-teen/early-20s heroine addicts of the late 1960s/early70s, and discovered that the overwhelming majority were living ordinary lives in the suburbs.
Yep, those former debased, derelict addicts were living ordinary suburban lives. There was nothing. It was over, long over.
There are others who have had the "non-experience" I've had. I'mWanderWoman, just please wait for other comments from those of us who know. Kindest regards ~~
HorseJeff
Sun, 06/05/2011 - 01:29
Permalink
I'm pretty sure Kurvon didn't "slam" her
In fact, he did just the opposite.
--"A horse doesn't care how much you care you know until he knows how much you care."
massive
Sun, 01/08/2012 - 22:17
Permalink
catswalkintoabar-I needed to
catswalkintoabar-I needed to hear this. Thank you. I began attending AA on my 18th b day. How sad this sounds to me now. Hmmm I wanted to stop. I did on my own 2 weeks before I met Tom Catton who wrote a book recently The Mindful Addict. Anyway, Tom told me about AA on the beach and I went. I had already stopped drinking on my won for two weeks after drinking daily for many months. There were months I didnt drink daily.
Im glad to hear that you are drinking normally. I wonder. I left AA last May after trying to make it safer. The resistance was so sick and horrible it forced me to dig on the web and I found OP then ST then after weeks and months of reading when I went to my weekly woman's meeting I was hearing Chapter 5 and It sounded ridiculous. I found ST and OP January 2009. It was then that I was doing the inside work. I made some change but it was so horrific and isolating. Two years past. But Exactly a year ago after Tracy White was murdered and Kristine Cass was murdered along with her daughter and the way the A member justified the killings and the rapes I was so disgusted I went to my meeting and told the women why I was leaving. But the way you described AA as I place where you go forever...why? I actually saw that many of the old-timers unless they did outside work got sicker as they stayed. I felt so free when I left. I went to some SMart Recovery meetings and I Created a blogtalkradio, and I am making a film about it. A Documentary.
I am involved with activism to make change regarding AA and criminal behavior in meetings and it's culture.
Again, thank you for your post! www.leavingaa.com
Massive
micha
Fri, 05/06/2011 - 23:43
Permalink
Im one of those..My mother
Im one of those..My mother joined alanon when I was 12.She had me brainwashed into thinking I was an alcoholic before I ever had a drink..Of course when I did start expirementing with alcohol the self fulfilling prophecy had just begun..Im here to tell you that I have struggled with guilt and shame my entire adult life as a result of 12 step nonsense..I am now 41 and still can't shake the label placed on me at a young age..I have had periods of sobriety for as long as 8 years..And durring those periods was called a dry drunk..Damned if you do damned if you don't..I still drink when I choose and have drank excessively on and off for years at a time..Just a few beers after work is pretty much it anymore..People can say what they want..But I know this,labels and stigma,guilt and shame,all caused by AA and 12 steps have caused more destruction in my life and family than alcohol ever did..Especially when you wake up after all those years and realise it was all bullshit..With me drinking is not a disease or even a disorder..It is a choice and that's it..Personally,I find myself drinking more when life gets painful and less when things are going well..
Micah
massive
Sun, 01/08/2012 - 22:25
Permalink
forced to drink the koolaid
micha- how sad. Your post really made me sad. Is it that I realate in some ways. Our stories are so different. But I think like you it is so damaging to believe this Bullshit. I say a Dr Phil that made me so made as they bullied a 25 year old. But for me at age 18 to drink such cult crap...it makes me sad and furious sometimes.
I have two sons. ANd one started to drink and I was still in AA. I told him he had 50 % chance. Oh my GOD! This created more problems. Long story short, as I saw the light, I told him all I learned from Stanton Peele and Rational ANd Smart Recovery.
He now drinks moderately and has one beer and stops easily. I am so grateful I left AA when I did. I just wish I knew this a few years sooner. My sons laugh with me now as I make fun of AA and it's stupidity. But it did hurt him to say the things I did. I even had therapists that thought this crap was true.
Massive
flannigan
Sat, 05/07/2011 - 10:48
Permalink
Returning to social drinking
Some can, others can't. Make sure which one you are.
istj04
Sat, 06/04/2011 - 21:09
Permalink
Its all a CHOICE, regardless
Those who allegedly "can't", CAN, but CHOOSE NOT TO! Alcohol is an inanimate object that does not MAKE its ingestor ingest it, anymore then your computer keyboard MAKES you type your response to this on it! THAT is the "side" people addicted to alcohol need to understand.
BlackandTan
Fri, 10/14/2011 - 06:51
Permalink
CHOICE
Amen istj04! If we continue to say "some can, others can't" aren't we just perpetuating the AA "disease" myth that some are destined, predisposed, defective or some other nonsense? If a person chooses not to drink, good for them, but it is just that, a choice, it's never a matter of can or cannot.
"Jesus Christ! If that's a big book he must be a fucking giant! Run! Save yourselves! Run!"
Cheers!
Jesus-is-Fraud
Mon, 03/05/2012 - 04:36
Permalink
Black and Tan
LOL - I have no wish to go back to using... I am already fucked up enough without MORE bullshit...
I think using is like watching movies on TV where there are 10 minutes of adds for every 1 minute of movie... I just don't have time for the bullshit.
Especially the bullshit of the active addicts.
But to be honest - when I have seen the very infrequent shows on home brewing and all where people make all sorts of really amazingly excellent wines and beers - I DO miss not being able to drink the beer and wine, I just don't miss not getting drunk....
And one of my favourites was Black and Tan - the really dark and strong stouts and lemonade - if only it came bottled and in alcohol free versions that were as great as or nearly so as the brewed versions.....
If I could get unbrewed stout, I would probably be very inclined to buy a carton of it for the taste and tonic properties of it...... very nice with some lemonaid on a hot day.
The carbonated grape juice or fake wines tend to remind me of tasteless fizzy fruit flavoured water.
But the fascination with really brilliant homebrew also extends to being engrossed in pictures of food and great home cooking in cook books and magazines etc...
I think it's the natural taste of good healthy food that is the appeal here - real food that is made by people with care and skill, instead of the factory made crap....
But I am not willing to become intoxicated again - because I don't like being stoned on anything.
Oddly enough I was on a morning walk and we have recently had lots of heavy rains and I saw a whole heap of "golden tops" or magic mushrooms popping up - and I immediately recognised them and went, "Pretty little things - aren't they!" - like lovely little pieces of organic jewelery, paused for a moment to admire them and then just kept on walking.
But I still am every inch an addict..... When I am really tired and run down - "Why not have a strong coffee? Why not have 10 of them?"
Fuck........
I drank addictively from the very MOMENT I had my first drug - which was dads home brewed beer...
LOL
But that issue as stated in the NA basic text, "We must change out old playmates, play grounds and play things" - which is also a derivative of AA's "We must be willing to change all of our old ideas about right and wrong etc".... - well it is true.
If you really are an addict - then staying out of the OLD environments and the people who function in the shit is a very important decision to make and keep.
So anyway....
Charlie B
Fri, 01/06/2012 - 08:10
Permalink
Some probably can't
I suppose for me drinking may be a little like smoking. I found it really tough to quit smoking and can't imagine ever smoking in moderation. If I had been a more of a casual social smoker then I might feel differently.
aasux
Sat, 06/04/2011 - 22:41
Permalink
But we can't control our
But we can't control our choices...wahhhh, we can't help it....wahhh, it's our disease....
I hear ya, it does start with a choice. No chemical ever forced itself into my body. I chose to start, I chose to stop. I had a lot of "encouragement" to stop, but I did choose it. Yes, mandatory drug testing is a good motivator, but it is still my choice. I choose sobriety. I choose not to buy anything AA. It is a club for relapsers, predators, and those otherwise unable to exercise free will and thought.
istj04
Sun, 06/05/2011 - 08:43
Permalink
Not "unable", UNWILLING
There is no "unable" in "not exercising free will and thought", its UNWILLING TO! 12-Step group attendees are a bunch of pathetic wastes of oxygen consumption, who REFUSE to utilize their own mental and physical ability to END a destructive BEHAVIOR (which CAN BE CHANGED!). If more of them would DIE as a result of their unwillingness, the group numbers would drop, groups would vaporize, and this problem called "12-Step groups" would DIE OFF (as I wish their adherents would!).
massive
Sun, 01/08/2012 - 22:27
Permalink
I have free will. I am not a follower. I am not powerless
So true. Its very sad to go to a young people event. I was horrified by what I saw there. It should be illegal for a minor to attend AA. It too fucking filled with sexual predators.
Massive
Dennis M.
Wed, 06/29/2011 - 13:22
Permalink
I have one to four beers
I have one to four beers a few times a year. I enjoy a cold one in the right setting and I have no shame in that. I'm now in my forties and I don't feel any physical cravings for alcohol, and I don't even care for any more at a certain point, usually between beer three and four. I don't drink more than one per hour when I do. I can also have just one at a restaraunt or gathering and leave it alone. Everyone is different. There are people like Orange that are literally taking a risk with their lives by having a beer, but I think there are plenty of people that drank excessively in their youth as just typical behavior amongst their peers. Then some of those people get a public intox or DUI charge, are forced to attend AA and are programmed with damaging lies. I was indoctrinated into steppism at 10 and grew up with a very distorted view of alcohol and alcoholism. I take responsibility for my actions (multiple PI arrests and 3 DUIs between the ages of 19 and 24) but truly believe my drinking would have been less severe at times had I not been programmed with the self-fulfilling prophecy that I would drink myself to oblivion.
I need to also mention that while I do enjoy the mild buzz a little, I don't enjoy it long and no longer feel the need to keep drinking to intensify it. When I have a beer it is because the taste, texture, etc. sound refreshing. If I started to really crave the buzz and was looking for an escape of sorts, that would be much different. I don't drink to try and relieve stress or escape anything. Having a cold beer at a BBQ with friends on a hot summer day or at a concert or festival is nothing more than a nice refreshment to me. As long as it stays this way, I see no reason to deprive myself of this simple pleasure.
Dennis M.
"They are not at fault, they seem to have been brainwashed that way."
massive
Sun, 01/08/2012 - 21:59
Permalink
Drinking normally
Dennis - I loved to here this. The reason is being that I think the AA all or nothing are not true. I too was brainwashed by AA think when I was 18. Although I wanted to quit for good on my own which I did, but after all the sexual predators who preyed on me I did want to leave AA and I should have. But I did not.
Fast forward 36 years. I left in May. But now I look back and wonder about not drinking at all forever.
I really like Kenneth Anderson's way, Hams Harm Reduction. I think that is what DUI's need to be taught as well as our teens.
I think out court s and culture has be severely brainwashed with the all or nothing abstinence AA way.
Massive
aasux
Wed, 06/29/2011 - 10:39
Permalink
I fully intend to drink again
I fully intend to drink again when I'm not being tested. My DOC was opiates, which I fully intend to NEVER do again. Alcohol was never a big deal, an occasional red wine with a nice steak or a beer with friends, but I can count on one hand the times I got drunk, and it wasn't pleasurable. I do not buy the disease theory, and I do not believe alcohol is a gateway drug to relapse. That's all steppism dogma intended to scare you into attendance and conformity. Screw them. Cheers.
marionette davis
Sat, 12/10/2011 - 23:37
Permalink
I'm Marionette...
...and I have this disease.
"I fully intend to drink again..."
Yeah, right sweatheart! You let me know how this works out for you, darling. Of course it's a fucking disease! Everything in life is, INCLUDING your denial. Good luck, Fucktard.
"take what you want and give it away".
Oh, and keep coming back!
m
massive
Sun, 01/08/2012 - 22:02
Permalink
not a disease
aasaux- and I do not believe alcohol is a gateway drug to relapse. That's all steppism dogma intended to scare you into attendance and conformity. Screw them. Cheers.
I agree. It's a lie. Some I believe should not drink at all. But others can learn to use harm reduction.
Massive
BlackandTan
Fri, 10/14/2011 - 06:35
Permalink
Totally possible
Hello,
I started drinking when I was around 15 years old and got quite drunk that very first time. I drank heavily, even daily, all through high school and first years of college. I got arrested a handfull of times ending with my last, and final arrest at age 23. I can honestly say that almost everyday between age 15 and 23 I was either drunk, getting drunk, stoned, or hungover. Then after that last arrest I was forced into AA. I stopped drinking for 9 months before ever joining the AA. I was in AA for about 2 years after that before I realized that it is such a backwards cult and I left. I stayed dry for a year after leaving. Then I realized that whether in AA or not and still avoiding "the devil drink," I was no closer to freedom than I was when I was drinking excessively or in the mind-numbing AA cult, I was still a prisoner. If drinking truly is a choice, and it 100% is, then anybody (even those falsely diagnosed with a made-up disease) can safely drink again. After long discussions with my wife, we decided that it would be worth a try. What's the worst that could happen? I could always choose to stop again. So, in January of this year, I drank my first beer in almost 5 years. And you know what? I was not suddenly stricken with the "phenomenon of craving" nor did I instantly become stark raving mad, I just enjoyed a good beer with dinner and felt totally at ease about my choice. Ever since then, I occasionally enjoy a drink, or a few drinks. I am trying to reestablish connections with old friends (old "drinking pals"), those friends whom AA told me I could not have a realtionship with. At the end of a long work week I sometimes enjoy a glass of good single malt and with dinner I sometimes have a glass of wine or beer. I exprerience no guilt or shame, I am totally at ease with my choice...because my life and yours as well as our choice to drink or not is just that, a choice, a 100% personal choice.
My wife and I have a child now, a beautiful baby girl, and I feel that I can be a better man, husband, and father without irrationally avoiding a substance that has no power over me. I know that die-hard AA cultists would say that I am insane and letting my "disease" dictate my life or whatever. Well, to those die-hard AAs I would say, "Get a life of your own."
Believe it or not, choosing to drink again has turned out to be one of the best choices I have ever made. The disease theory is absolute nonsense. Drinking is completely a choice and once I understood that, the compulsion to drink excessively was gone. I am in control of my life now, and would encourage others to take control of their own lives as well.
"Jesus Christ! If that's a big book he must be a fucking giant! Run! Save yourselves! Run!"
Cheers!
dolson
Tue, 11/01/2011 - 18:18
Permalink
Not me.
I have tried drinking repeatedly after periods - from weeks to years - of being dry.
Attempting to control my drinking never worked. Alcohol holds no benefit for me.
I am with KURVON on this.
Have a coke.
Go ahead, enjoy yourselves - it's getting late, much later than you think.
Orange
Wed, 01/04/2012 - 15:41
Permalink
Attempting to control my drinking never worked.
Yes, I'm with you on that one too.
Did you know that Dr. Kenneth Blum, who discovered the first gene for alcoholism, gave an interview that is reprinted in the SOS book, and in it he said that genetic alcoholics cannot moderate — that total abstinence is best for them.
See "SOS Sobriety, The Proven Alternative to 12-Step Programs" by James Christopher.
Bibliography entry here:
http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-bibliography.html#SOS
I'm a genetic alcoholic, just like my father and his mother, and total abstinence is actually pretty darned easy, but all attempts at moderate or controlled drinking failed. It just never worked out. It's like alcohol clouds my brain and moderate drinking looks too darned wimpy to be any fun.
So I just don't drink any alcohol at all, and life is good.
It could well be that the people who don't have the genes for alcoholism really can just taper off and moderate and live successful happy lives with the occasional drink. But I know that isn't my fate. I think it really comes down to a matter of two distinctly different kinds of people.
massive
Sun, 01/08/2012 - 22:32
Permalink
honest discussion
At least we can have an intelligent discussion here! Thank you.
Massive
Banana
Thu, 01/05/2012 - 00:12
Permalink
I think it's just that when I
I think it's just that when I get buzzed (which happens quite easily- 1 or 2 glasses of wine) I lose my inhibition and make poor decisions. Not so much an uncontrollable craving but the first 2 make me kind of brave and happy and not as smart so I think I can keep drinking. It's more of a loss of inhibition. Then I lose count and wake up with a terrible headache. :)
And that's ridiculous what they say about not maturing while you're still drinking! I was 15 when I started, 35 when I quit. In that 20 years I made a career, got married, had kids, and was 100x more mature! Whatever. (said like a 15 year-old)
marietta davis
Sun, 01/08/2012 - 18:07
Permalink
Social drinker.
Social drinker.
Amour013
Sun, 01/08/2012 - 20:00
Permalink
Oh boy....
All it takes is simply reading a paragraph or two for Marietta to have everything all figured out.
She's become the Elizabeth Cady Stanton of the OPF.
massive
Thu, 01/05/2012 - 01:26
Permalink
banana- Love it!!!
banana- Love it!!!
Massive
dolson
Fri, 01/06/2012 - 05:19
Permalink
Genectic
I am a genetically troubled drinker. When I start, I physically have a hard time stopping. The physical withdrawal is horrendous. So I cannot safely use alcohol.
Go ahead, enjoy yourselves - it's getting late, much later than you think.
Amour013
Sun, 01/08/2012 - 18:52
Permalink
Nuff Said
Nuff said.... that's a reasonable and rational explanation. No need for all the fluff associated with the AA dogma..... you simply STOP or continue to poison yourself and be sick. It's your choice at this point.
billybudd
Sun, 01/08/2012 - 20:51
Permalink
hack hack
OP's own Carrie Nation brandishes her incisive remedy with a hatchet. Hew or be hewn.
Pages